Sunday, June 10, 2018

Dierks Bentley



*20-11-1975 Phoenix, AZ
4th version
by Praguefrank

SESSIONS

2001 Nashville, TN – Dierks Bentley (Producer: Dierk Bentley, Mike Ward)
001 ALWAYS BE ME Dangling Rope DBCD 1001
002 DON'T LEAVE ME IN LOVE Dangling Rope DBCD 1001
003 MIDNIGHT RADIO Dangling Rope DBCD 1001
004 BARTENDERS, BARSTOOLS AND BARMAIDS Dangling Rope DBCD 1001
005 WALKING PAPERS Dangling Rope DBCD 1001
006 WHISKEY TEARS Dangling Rope DBCD 1001
007 LIVING SINGLE Dangling Rope DBCD 1001
008 WHY DO YOU LOVE ME Dangling Rope DBCD 1001
009 NOT THROUGH LOVING YOU Dangling Rope DBCD 1001
010 HOME IS WHERE THE HURT IS Dangling Rope DBCD 1001
Spring 2003 Station West, Nashville, TN/Ocean Way Nashville, 1200 17th Ave. South, Nashville, TN – Dierks Bentley (Dierks Bentley [vcl], Bryan Sutton [ac gt/banjo], Steven Sheehan [ac gt], J.T. Corenflos [el gt], Mike Johnson/Rusty Danmyer [steel], Jimmy Carter [bass], Steve Brewster [drums], Russell Terrell, Wes Hightower, Iona Heins [bck vcl], + The Del McCoury Band. Producer Brett Beavers)
011 WHAT WAS I THINKIN' Capitol 17718-2/7243-5-39814-2 [edit:] 17718-2
012 WISH IT WOULD BREAK Capitol 7243-5-39814-2
013 FORGET ABOUT YOU Capitol 7243-5-39814-2
014 I CAN ONLY THINK OF ONE Capitol 7243-5-39814-2
015 MY LAST NAME Capitol 7243-5-39814-2
016 BARTENDERS, ETC.... Capitol 7243-5-39814-2
017 IS ANYBODY LOVING YOU THESE DAYS Capitol 7243-5-39814-2
018 MY LOVE WILL FOLLOW YOU Capitol 7243-5-39814-2
019 HOW AM I DOIN' Capitol 7243-5-39814-2
020 DISTANT SHORE Capitol 7243-5-39814-2
021 I BOUGHT THE SHOES Capitol 7243-5-39814-2
022 WHISKEY TEARS Capitol 7243-5-39814-2
Spring 2003 Station West, Nashville, TN/Ocean Way Nashville, 1200 17th Ave. South, Nashville, TN – Dierks Bentley and Del McCoury Band
023 TRAIN TRAVELIN' Capitol 7243-5-39814-2
2003 [sessions for Livin', Lovin', Losin': Songs of the Louvin Brothers] Nashville, TN – Harley Allen and Diersk Bentley
024 I DON'T BELIEVE YOU'VE MET MY BABY  Universal South B0000458-02
ca early 2004 [sessions for Amazing Grace 3: A Country Salute To Gospel] Nashville, TN - Dierks Bentley
025 IT IS NO SECRET Sparrow 95556-2
ca early 2005 Nashville, TN – Dierks Bentley (Dierks Bentley [vcl], Bryan Sutton [ac gt/banjo], Del McCoury [ac gt], Steve Sheehan [ac gt], J.T. Corenflos [el gt], Rod Janzen [el gt], Rob McCoury [banjo], Ronnie McCoury [mandolin], Gary Morse [steel], Mike Bub [double bass], Jimmy Carter [bass gt], Steve Brewster [drums], Aubrey Haynie/Jason Carter [fiddle], Alison Krauss, Wes Hightower, Russell Terrell, Lona R. Heins [bck vcl] + The Del McCoury Band*)
026 LOT OF LEAVIN' LEFT TO DO Capitol 66475
027 COME A LITTLE CLOSER Capitol 66475
028 CAB OF MY TRUCK Capitol 66475
029 SETTLE FOR A SLOWDOWN Capitol 66475
030 DOMESTIC, LIGHT AND COLD Capitol 66475
031 GOOD THINGS HAPPEN Capitol 66475
032 DOWN ON EASY STREET Capitol 66475
033 SO SO LONG Capitol 66475
034 MODERN DAY DRIFTER Capitol 66475
035 GOOD MAN LIKE ME* Capitol 66475
036 GONNA GET THERE SOMEDAY Capitol 66475
20 July 2005 [sessions for Songs of the Year] Blackbird Studios, 2806 Azalea Place, Nashville, TN - Dierks Bentley and  George Jones (Fletcher Watson [ac gt], JT Cornflas [el gt], Gary Morse [steel], Jimmy Carter [bass], Tommy Hardin [drums], Aubrey Haynie [fiddle]. Producers: Chris Farren, Brett Beavers)
037 MURDER ON MUSIC ROW Cracker Barrel no number
2006 Ocean Way Nashville, 1200 17th Ave. South, Nashville, TN - Dierks Bentley Dierks Bentley [vcl], Bryan Sutton [ac gt/mandolin], Jimmy Carter [bass gt], Steve Brewster [drums], Aubrey Haynie [fiddle], The Grascals)
038 EVERY MILE A MEMORY Capitol 67320
039 CAN'T L:IVE IT DOWN Capitol 67320
040 LONG TRIP ALONE Capitol 67320
041 THAT DON'T MAKE IT EASY LOVING ME Capitol 67320
042 SOON AS YOU CAN Capitol 67320
043 TRYING TO STOP YOUR LEAVING Capitol 67320
044 HOPE FOR ME YET Capitol 67320
045 THE HEAVEN I'M HEADED TO Capitol 67320
046 FREE AND EASY (DOWN THE ROAD I GO) Capitol 67320
047 BAND OF BROTHERS Capitol 67320
048 PRODIGAL SON'T PRAYER - (WITH THE GRASCALS) Capitol 67320
10 June 2006 [live] Fillmore, Denver, CO - Dierks Bentley
04800 Intro
04801 LOT OF LEAVIN' LEFT TO DO 0999-2-09070-2
04802 CAB OF MY TRUCK
04803 HOW AM I DOIN'
04804 DOMESTIC, LIGHT AND COLD
04805 FORGET ABOUT YOU
04806 FREE AND EASY (DOWN THE ROAD I GO) 0999-2-09070-2
04807 SETTLE FOR A SLOWDOWN
04808 EVERY MILE A MEMORY
04809 WISH IT WOULD BREAK
04810 CAN'T LIVE IT DOWN
04811 GOOD MAN LIKE ME
04812 MY LAST NAME
04813 LONG TRIP ALONE
04814 MY LOVE WILL FOLLOW YOU
04815 SO SO LONG 0999-2-09070-2
04816 COME A LITTLE CLOSER 0999-2-09070-2
04817 WHAT WAS I THINKIN'
04818 AIN'T LIVIN' LONG LIKE THIS
04819 WHERE THE WIND DON'T BLOW
04820 FOLSOM PRISON BLUES
tracks above issued on DVD Live And Loud At The Fillmore, Capitol 0946-3-73998-9
2006 [sessions for She Was Country When Country Wasn't Cool: A Tribute To Barbara Mandrell] Nashville, TN – Dierks Bentley
049 FAST LANES AND COUNTRY ROADS
ca 2007 [live] Grand Ole Opry, 2802 Opryland Drive, Nashville, TN - Dierks Bentley
04901 A HOUSE OF GOLD RCA 720939
2008 Nashville, TN - Dierks Bentley, * and Sarah Buckley
050 WITH THE BAND 0999-2-09070-2
051 SWEET AND WILD* 0999-2-09070-2
2008 Blackbird Studios, Nashville, TN//Ocean Way Nashville, 1200 17th Ave. South, Nashville, TN/Station West Studios, Nashville, TN – Dierks Bentley (Dierks Bentley [vcl], Rod Janzen [gt], Bryan Sutton [gt/banjo/ bouzouki/ mandolin], Mike McCready [el gt], J.T. Corenflos [el gt], Randy Kohrs [dobro], Rob McCoury/ Brett Beavers [banjo], Ronnie McCoury [mandolin/bck vcl], Gary Morse [steel], Alan Bartram [upright bass], Steve Misamore/ Steve Brewster [drums/ percussion], Jason Carter [fiddle], Charles Judge [keyboards/ percussion], Liz Beavers, Caleb Beavers, Emily Beavers, Greg Mangum, Mike Dungan, Autumn House, Joanna Carter , Lona Heid, Jimmy Harnen, Patty Griffin, Steve Hodge, Russell Terrell [bck vcl]. Producers: Brett Beavers, Dierks Bentley)
052 LIFE ON THE RUN Capitol 0999-5-02158-2
052 SIDEWAYAS Capitol 0999-5-02158-2
053 FEEL THAT FIRE Capitol 0999-5-02158-2
054 I WANNA MAKE YOU CLOSE YOUR EYES Capitol 0999-5-02158-2
055 SHE COMES Capitol 0999-5-02158-2
056 HERE WE GO Capitol 0999-5-02158-2
057 I CAN1T FORGET HER Capitol 0999-5-02158-2
058 BEAUTIFUL WORLD w. Patty Griffin Capitol 0999-5-02158-2
059 LITTLE HEARTWRECKER Capitol 0999-5-02158-2
060 YOU HOLD ME TOGETHER Capitol 0999-5-02158-2
061 BETTER BELIEVER Capitol 0999-5-02158-2
062 PRAY Capitol 0999-5-02158-2
063 LAST CALL w. Ronnie McCoury Capitol 0999-5-02158-2
12 January 2009 [live] The Apple Store SoHo, New York City – Dierks Bentley
06301 FEEL THAT FIRE
06302 SIDEWAYS
06303 I WANNA MAKE YOU CLOSE YOUR EYES
06304 LIFE ON THE RUN
06305 TRYING TO STOP YOUR LEAVING
06306 FREE AND EASY (DOWN THE ROAD I GO)
Tracks above issued on EP iTunes: Live In SoHo
2010 Blackbird Studios, Nashville, TN/ Brooklyn Recording, New York City/ Minutia Sound, ?/ Sound Emporium, Nashville, TN – Dierks Bentley (with: Christ Thile [-1], Punch Brothers [-2], Miranda Lambert [-3], Jamey Johnson [-4], Del McCoury [-5], Kris Kristofferson [-7] (Dierks Bentley [vcl], Chris Eldridge [ac gt], Bryan Sutton [ac gt/ resonator gt], Guthrie Trapp [el gt], Scott Vestal / Rob McCoury / Noam Pikelny [banjo], Ronnie McCoury [mandola/  mandolin], Tim O'Brien [mandolin/ hmny vcl], Chris Thile [mandolin/hmny vcl], Rob Ickes [dobro/ Weissenborn], Randy Kohrs [Weissenborn], Mike Bub / Paul Kowert / Glen Worff  [bass], Jon Randall Stewart [el bass/ gt/ hmny vcl]     Larry Atamanuik [drums/percussion], John Gardner [drums/ percussion], Sam Bush [fiddle/ mandolin/ hmny vcl], Jason Carter [fiddle], Gabe Witcher [fiddle/ hmny vcl], Stuart Duncan [cello/ fiddle/ octave fiddle], Vince Gill, Sonya Isaacs, Alison Krauss, Chris Stapleton [hmny vcl])
064 UP ON THE RIDGE Capitol 85410-2
065 FALLIN' FOR YOU Capitol 85410-2
066 SENOR (TALES OF YANKEE POWER) -1,2 Capitol 85410-2
067 ROVIN' GAMBLER -2 Capitol 85410-2
068 DRAW ME A MAP Capitol 85410-2
069 BAD ANGEL -3,4 Capitol 85410-2
070 FIDDLIN' AROUND Capitol 85410-2
071 YOU'RE DEAD TO ME Capitol 85410-2
072 PRIDE (IN THE NAME OF LOVE) -2,5 Capitol 85410-2
073 LOVES GROWS WILD Capitol 85410-2
074 BOTTLE TO THE BOTTOM -6 Capitol 85410-2
075 DOWN IN THE MINE Capitol 85410-2
2010 unknown – Dierks Bentley
076 AM I THE ONLY ONE
2011 Echo Mountain Studios, Ashevile, NC/Minutia Sound, ?/Ocean Way, Nashville, TN/The Metal Building, ?/West Wing, ?/Station West, Nashville, TN – Dierks Bentley (Diesrk Bentley [vcl], Brett Beavers [ac gt], Jim Beavers [ac gt], Steven Sheehan [ac gt], Bryan Sutton [ac gt/Guitjo/ mandolin], Luke Wooten [el gt], J.T. Corenflos /Tom Bukovac / Kenny Greenberg / Rob McNelley [el gt], Jaren Johnston [ac gt/ percussion/ bck vcl], Jedd Hughes  [gt], Randy Kohrs [dobro], Tim O'Brian [mandolin], Gary Morse [steel], Scotty Sanders [steel], Dan Dugmore [lap steel], Michael Rhodes/ Jimmy Carter [bass], Steve Brewster [drums/ percussion], Shannon Forrest [drums], Eric Darken [percussion], Sam Bush / Larry Franklin [fiddle], Andy Leftwich [fiddle/ mandolin], Mike Rojas [accordion/ piano], Evie Bentley, Caylin Cervetti, Perry Coleman, Morgan Hayes, Lona Heins, Chris Stapleton, Jon Randall Stewart, Russell Terrell [bck vcl])
077 AM I THE ONLY ONE EMI 94714-2 
078 GONNA DIE YOUNG EMI 94714-2
079 TIP IT ON BACK EMI 94714-2  [radio edit:] EP
080 HOME EMI 94714-2 
081 DIAMONDS MAKE BABIES EMI 94714-2
082 IN MY HEAD EMI 94714-2 
083 BREATHE YOU IN EMI 94714-2
084 WOODS EMI 94714-2 
085 WHEN YOU GONNA COME AROUND EMI 94714-2 
086 5-1-5-0 EMI 94714-2
087 HEART OF A LONELY GIRL EMI 94714-2
088 THINKING OF YOU EMI 94714-2 
2012 unknown – Dierks Bentley
089 COUNTRY AND COLD CANS
090 GRAB A BEER
091 BACK PORCH
092 SUMMER ON THE FIRE
tracks above issued on EP Country and Cold Cans
2013 Blackbird Studios, Nashville, TN/ Ocean Way Nashville, Nashville, TN/ The Red Room, Nashville, TN – Dierks Benrley (Dierks Bentley [vcl],  Dan Dugmore [gt/dobro], Charlie Worsham [gt/ banjo/ mandolin/ ukulele], Ilya Toshinskiy [gt/ banjo/ mandolin], Ross Copperman [gt/mandolin/ keyboards/ programming/bck vcl],  Kenny Greenberg [gt],  Jaren Johnston [ac gt/banjo/ bck vcl], Bryan Sutton [ac gt/ mandolin], Brian Layson [el gt/ banjo/ mandolin], Ryan Tyndell [el gt/mandolin/ keyboards/ percussion/bck vcl], Jedd Hughes [el gt], Dan Hochhalter [banjo/ fiddle], Craig Wright/ Fred Eltringham [drums/ percussion], F. Reid Shippen [percussion], Rob Hajacos [fiddle], Jonathan Yudkin [strings], Mickey Raphael [harmonica], Jason Lehning [Hammond b-3 organ/ keyboards/ synthesizer], Kacey Musgraves, Chris Stapleton, Hillary Lindsey, Jessi Alexander, Jon Randall, Sam Ashworth [bck vcl])
093 BOURBON IN KENTUCKY Capitol B0019404-02 
094 SAY YOU DO Capitol B0019404-02 
095 I HOLD ON Capitol B0019404-02 
096 PRETTY GIRLS Capitol B0019404-02 
097 HERE ON EARTH Capitol B0019404-02 
098 DRUNK ON A PLANE Capitol B0019404-02 
099 FIVE Capitol B0019404-02 
100 RISER Capitol B0019404-02 
101 SOUNDS OF SUMMER Capitol B0019404-02 
102 DAMN THESE DREAMS Capitol B0019404-02 
103 BACK PORCH Capitol B0019404-02 
104 HURT SOMEBODY Capitol B0019404-02  
2015 Arlyn Studios, Austin, TX/  Blackbird Studios, Nashville, TN/  Buckjump Studios, New Orleans, LA/  Monster Island Studio, Nashville, TN/  My Place, Franklin, TN/  Ocean Way Studios, Nashville, TN/ Southern Ground Nashville, Nashville, TN/ The Red Room, Nashville, TN – Dierks Bentley )Dierks Bentley [vcl], Luke Dick [gt], Bryan Sutton [ac gt], Charlie Worsham [gt], Dan Dugmore [el gt/ steel], Jaren Johnston [gt/ bck vcl], Jedd Hughes [ gt], Luke Laird [gt/ bck vcl], Danny Rader  [bouzouki/ gt/ keyboards], Jerry Douglas [dobro],
Russ Pahl [steel], Ross Copperman [bass/ gt/ keyboards],  Lee Hendricks / Tony Lucido [bass], Aaron Sterling [drums/ percussion], Fred Eltringham, Craig Wright  [drums],
Troy "Trombone Shorty" Andrews/ Roy Agee [trombone], Jeff Coffin [sax], Mike Haynes [trumpet], Sam Ashworth, Natalie Hemby, Elle King. Hillary Lindsey, Maren Morris, Micah Wilshire, Jessi Alexander [bck vcl])
105 BLACK Capitol B0024745-02
106 PICK UP Capitol B0024745-02
107 I'LL BE THE MOON Capitol B0024745-02
108 WHAT THE HELL DID I SAY Capitol B0024745-02
109 SOMEWHERE ON A BEACH Capitol B0024745-02
110 FREEDOM Capitol B0024745-02
111 WHY DO I FEEL Capitol B0024745-02
112 ROSES AND A TIME MACHINE Capitol B0024745-02
113 ALL THE WAY TO ME Capitol B0024745-02
114 DIFFERENT FOR GIRLS Capitol B0024745-02
115 MARDI GRAS Capitol B0024745-02
116 LIGHT IT UP Capitol B0024745-02
117 CAN'T BE REPLACED  Capitol B0024745-02
2017 Telluride, CO – Dierks Bentley, with Brothers Osborne [-1], Brandi Carlile [-2] (Producer: Jon Randall, Ross Copperman)
118 BURNING MAN -1 B0028286-02  
119 THE MOUNTAIN  B0028286-02  
120 LIVING  B0028286-02
121 WOMAN, AMEN  B0028286-02  
122 YOU CAN'T BRING ME DOWN  B0028286-02
123 NOTHING ON BUT THE STARS  B0028286-02
124 GOODBYE IN TELLURIDE  B0028286-02
125 MY RELIGION  B0028286-02
126 ONE WAY  B0028286-02
127 SON OF THE SUN  B0028286-02
128 STRANGER TO MYSELF  B0028286-02
129 TRAVELIN' LIGHT -2  B0028286-02  
130 HOW I'M GOING OUT  B0028286-02




ALBUMS
Dangling Rope DBCD 1001 Don't Leave Me In Love: Always Be Me; Don't Leave Me In Love; Midnight Radio; Bartenders, Barstools And Barmaids; Walking Papers; Whiskey Tears; Living Single; Why Do You Love Me; Not Through Loving You; Home Is Where The Hurt Is - 01
Capitol 7243-5-39814-2 Dierks Bentley: What Was I Thinkin'; Wish It Would Break; Forget About You; I Can Only Think Of One; My Last Name; Bartenders, Etc; Is Anybody Loving You These Days; My Love Will Follow You; How Am I Doin'; Distant Shore; I Bought The Shoes; Whiskey Tears – 19-08-03
Capitol 7243-5-66475-2 Modern Day Drifter: Lot Of Leavin' Left To Do; Come A Little Closer; Cab Of My Truck; Settle For A Slowdown; Domestic, Light And Cold; Good Things Happen; Down On Easy Street; So So Long; Modern Day Drifter; Good Man Like Me (with The Del Mccoury Band); Gonna Get There Someday – 10-05-05
Capitol 0946-3-67320-2 Long trip Alone: Every Mile A Memory; Can't Live It Down; Long Trip Alone; That Don't Make It Easy Loving Me; Soon As You Can; Trying To Stop Your Leaving; Hope For Me Yet; The Heaven I'm Headed To; Free And Easy (Down The Road I Go); Band Of Brothers; Prodigal Son't Prayer (with The Grascals) – 17-10-06
Capitol 0999-2-09070-2 Greatest Hits/Every Mile a Memory 2003-2008: Free and Easy (Down the Road I Go)*; Trying to Stop Your Leaving; Sweet and Wild (w.Sarah Buxton)**; Come a Little Closer; How Am I Doin'; Every Mile a Memory; My Last Name; Lot of Leavin' Left to Do; With the Band**; Settle for a Slowdown; What Was I Thinkin'; Long Trip Alone; So So Long*; Come a Little Closer*; Lot of Leavin' Left to Do*; Wish It Would Break*; Free and Easy (Down the Road I Go)* - 06-05-08 (*live, **previously unissued)
Capitol 0999-5-02158-2 Feel That Fire: Life on the Run; Sideways; Feel That Fire; I Wanna Make You Close Your Eyes; She Comes, Here We Go; I Can't Forget Her; Beautiful World (w. Patty Griffin); Little Heartwrecker; You Hold Me Together; Better Believer; Pray; Last Call (w. Ronnie McCoury) - 03-02-09
Capitol 0999-6-85410-2-6 Up On the Ridge: Up On the Ridge; Fallin' For You; Senor (Tales of Yankee Power) (w. Chris Thile/Punch Brothers); Rovin' Gambler (w.Punch Brothers); Draw Me a Map; Bad Angel (w. Miranda Lambert/Jamey Johnson); Fiddlin' Around; You're Dead To Me; Pride (In the Name of Love) (w. Punch Brothers/Del McCoury; Loves Grows Wild; Bottle To the Bottom (w. Kris Kristofferson); Down In the Mine – 08-06-10
EMI Latin 0999-0-94714-2-9 Home:  Am I the Only One;  Gonna Die Young; Tip It On Back; Home; Diamonds Make Babies; In My Head; Breathe You In; Woods; When You Gonna Come Around; 5-1-5-0; Heart Of A Lonely Girl; Thinking of you – 07-02-12 
Capitol Nashville B0019404-02 Riser: Bourbon In Kentucky; Say You Do; I Hold On; Pretty Girls; Here On Earth; Drunk On a Plane; Five; Riser; Sounds of Summer; Damn These Dreams; Back Porch; Hurt Somebody – 25-02-14
Capitol Nashville B0024745-02 Black: Black; Pick Up; I'll Be The Moon; What The Hell Did I Say; Somewhere On A Beach; Freedom; Why Do I Feel; Roses and a Time Machine; All the Way to Me; Different For Girls; Mardi Gras; Light It Up; Can't Be Replaced – 27-05-16
Capitol Nashville B0028286-01*/B0028286-02 The Mountain: Burning Man (feat. Brothers Osborne);  The Mountain;  Living;  Woman, Amen;  You Can't Bring Me Down;  Nothing On But the Stars;  Goodbye in Telluride;  My Religion;  One Way;  Son of the Sun;  Stranger to Myself;  Travelin' Light (feat. Brandi Carlile);  How I'm Going Out – 08-06-18 (*double LP)


DVD
Capitol 0946-3-73998-9 Live and Loud at The Fillmore: Intro; Lot Of Leavin' Left To Do; Cab Of My Truck; How Am I Doin'; Domestic, Light And Cold; Forget About You; Free And Easy (Down The Road I Go); Settle For A Slowdown; Every Mile A Memory;  Wish It Would Break;  Can't Live It Down; Good Man Like Me; My Last Name; Long Trip Alone; My Love Will Follow You;  So So Long; Come A Little Closer; What Was I Thinkin'; Ain't Livin' Long Like This;  Where The Wind Don't Blow; Folsom Prison Blues – 20-03-07
EMI Video ? Video Hits: (tracks unknown) – 02-10-07
? Live From the Ryman: - 02-06-10

EPs
Capitol no # iTunes: Live From SoHo: Feel That Fire; Sideways; I Wanna Make You Close Your Eyes; Life On the Run; Trying to Stop Your Leaving; Free and Easy (Down the Road I Go) – 02-06-09
no label Country And Cold Cans: Country and Cold Cans; Grab a Beer; Back Porch; Summer On The Fire; Tip It On Back [radio edit] – 30-08-12

SINGLES
Capitol
7087-6-17718-2-4 What Was I Thinkin' (Edit);  Track 1 Repeats; Track 1 Repeats;  What Was I Thinkin' (Album Version) – 03 (promo)
DOL 7001  Come A Little Closer / Lot Of Leavin' Left To Do – 06
09463 70395 2 6  Every Mile A Memory – 06 (CD promo)
DOL 7003 Settle For A Slowdown/ [Jamie O‘ Neal:]  Love My Life - 06



No comments:

Post a Comment